REVIEW: Rumbleskin by Ames May Nunn – Fortyfive Downstairs


The myth of the American West is a lie. The western on film is a collection of folklore that is so steeped in tradition, we tend to think of these stories as historical. The tropes are so well known, that we’re conditioned to believe colonialist expansion across the United States was more explicitly violent and rough than it had been anywhere else. Cowboys and their horses and the weapons in their hands are iconic, but the fiction started to be weaved with fact even as history was happening.

In the early 1870s, the town of Palisade in Nevada was the site of a hoax, where visitors to the town were treated to gun shows and bank robberies as the new train rolled into town. An real-life Westworld.

At the same time, notorious bison hunter “Buffalo Bill” Cody – one of the most famous figures of the American West – turned his legend into Wild West stage shows, travelling the country playing to large audiences, cementing himself in the American narrative. Though one critic compared his acting to a “diffident schoolboy”, the shows continued through the turn of the century, even touring to Europe.

One of his most famous collaborations was with sharpshooter Annie Oakley, which was later immortalised in the Broadway musical, Annie Get Your Gun. The song “There’s No Business Like Show Business” is about Buffalo Bill trying to convince Annie to join his shows. Truth, as it is often said, is stranger than fiction.

In Ames May Nunn’s new play, Rumbleskin, the Western is given a further shake-up through a queer lens, full of tall tales and magic realism. Stories of a pregnant girl who turns into a monster to eat men’s faces. A woman who turns into a horse to buck off riders at the rodeo. A stranger who wanders into town, promising to help with farming, who is accused of unnatural acts in the dead of night.

I wondered why these theatre makers were choosing to tell these stories in the American vernacular, when transposing the work to Australia could also work. But colonisation in Australia and America’s “manifest destiny” play differently in the landscape of our histories. Our notions of bushrangers and squatters are a world away from the cowboy and the settler wagon trains.

Nunn’s text is deeply rooted in the tropes of the genre, determined to undermine it and twist it into a kind of fairytale about trans identities and how sharing stories is both fraught – lies can easily spread – and the only way that truth can get out sometimes.

The vignettes in this work are nested inside each other – one person tells a tale and another person inside that story tells another story – creating an interesting juxtaposition of reality and unreality. Perhaps the pregnant teen picked up by a truck driver on an empty stretch of highway is real, but the story he tells about a rodeo rider and the woman who is also a horse is not true. The deeper we get into the play, the more layers are uncovered and what is real becomes more difficult to parse. But that makes the whole experience rich with possibility and the audience is taken along for a ride that is fascinating and strange.

Sam Diamond’s patchwork set is evocative, playing with the idea that this history of America is sewn together through different perspectives. The moving rocky outcrops create an ever-changing landscape of rough terrain and a land to be tamed.

Giovanna Yate Gonzalez’s lighting is rich in the way it evokes time and place, sometimes holding characters in claustrophobic pools of light and other times casting shadows both eerie and compelling. When people start to shed their skins and wrap themselves in Sam Diamond’s cloaks, Gonzalez allows us to see just enough to believe the transformation is happening in front of our eyes.

The show is bookended by songs by composer Jacob Diamond, that capture the feeling of singing around a campfire, sharing wisdom and telling ghost stories. His work throughout the show, more songs and musical score, fleshes out the experience that is a country hoe-down mixed with more spiritual undertones.

The cast had their ups and downs on opening night. The accents got in the way sometimes and there were some stumbles with dialogue and missed cues. Each of them had their stand-out moments, but given they were all playing multiple characters, some of them were better at one than another. It was an odd experience.

Luke Wiltshire was captivating as Ditch, rodeo rider with a body covered in scars that told the story of a life. His work with Ziggy Resnick as Celia was filled with the possibility of young love, as they travelled across the country, from show to show to show. Their chemistry was electric. Michelle Perera is magnetic as Rodeo Ruth – the woman who becomes a horse.

Director Alonso Pineda keeps everything on track, slipping and sliding between stories, never letting the audience lose focus on who is who and what is happening. It’s a tricky juggling act that could easily get muddled without clear direction.

Nunn’s script evolves and changes much as their character’s do. Rumbleskin is full of passion for the cowboy millieu and the experience of trans people finding the skins they feel comfortable in. But the work is also sly, playing with our expectations and flipping the script on the American West in a new and fascinating way.

- Keith Gow, Theatre First

Rumbleskin is playing at Fortyfive Downstairs until July 28

Photos: Kimberley Summer


Comments