REVIEW: A Room with a View by E.M. Forster, adapted by Grace Chapple – Belvoir/Melbourne Theatre Company

Author E.M. Forster wrote six novels between 1901 and 1924, though the fifth one – Maurice, which was about a same-sex romance, wasn’t published until 1971, a year after he died. His work is proto-feminist in many ways, the author fascinated by the expectations placed upon women. Their relationships to men who are suitable and who are not is a running theme. He was credited at the time as a remarkably accomplished author for his age (he was 26 when his first book was published) and, in hindsight, for working out his closeted homosexuality by describing forbidden heterosexual romances.

A Room with a View was the third of his novels to be published, though it is the first he began writing under the working title “Lucy”. It is not considered his best work – his later works Howard’s End and A Passage to India are arguably that – but it is highly regarded in a career that included short stories, travel writing, biography, radio broadcast and criticism.

In 1946, he was offered $25,000 by 20th Century Fox (or $400,000 in today’s money) for the film rights to A Room with a View but Forster did not hold cinema in high regard. The studio offered him more but he declined. His most famous works, including View, became films in the 1980s – mostly produced by Merchant Ivory and starring a young Helena Bonham Carter.

I wonder what Forster would have made of the flurry of movie adaptations or the epic play inspired by Howard’s End, Matthew Lopez’s triumphant The Inheritance? I wonder what he would have made of Grace Chapple’s theatrical version of A Room with a View that opened at the Southbank Theatre this week, after premiering at Belvoir in Sydney last month?

Chapple has teamed up with director Hannah Godwin, with whom she collaborated on her earlier play, Never Closer, also at Belvoir. (A Melbourne production, directed by Marni Mount, had two seasons at Fortyfive Downstairs this year.) In the program, Chapple wonders if her adaptation might be considered fan fiction, but it is a faithful adaptation with a modern sensibility. Forster was trying to find a modern voice for his Lucy when he wrote the novel; Chapple has found a way to tell the story through a 2026 lens, without losing the charming appeal of the book.

The script leans into having fun with the sensibilities of the time, playing up the irrationality of the rules for women and how even the kind suggestion of swapping rooms so that Lucy and her Aunt can have the view they are seeking was looked upon as crossing a line. It feels on-trend with recent adaptations of My Brilliant Career and Pride & Prejudice, where the theatremakers have a reverence for the text but the production is irreverent.

Zoë Atkinson’s minimalist but versatile set, enhanced by Amelia Lever-Davidson’s clever lighting design, puts a large window frame centre stage. Other than a few chairs and a keyboard on wheels, the playing space is mostly empty, leaving the actors in Atkinson’s lush costumes to fill the void.

Nathalie Morris’ Lucy Honeychurch is a sublime creation with Morris finding a way to carry an inner strength while embracing the comedy, both implicit and explicit. Hayley McElhinney brings a real depth to Charlotte, who isn’t warning Lucy to do the right thing merely out of a sense of propriety, but because she’s lived a life that hasn’t worked out the way she’d hoped.

The ensemble fully embraces the chaos that goes on around Lucy and her aunt, with hilarious performances from Tom Conroy, Luke Wiltshire and scene-stealer Tomáš Kantor, in particular. Godwin keeps things on track, even as the drama rises and things are spinning out of control for Lucy. The tennis match scene is a masterclass in comic timing and the nude lake swimming scene has to be seen to be believed.

For all of Forster’s reticence about seeing his stories in other mediums, there were stage adaptations of his work during his lifetime – most notably Lance Sievking’s play of Howard’s End at the New Theatre in London n 1967. And if there was any concern he might not care for fan fiction, fifty years after View was published, he wrote an appendix titled “A View without a Room” that chronicles the lives of George and Lucy through the first two World Wars and leaves them waiting for the third. Leaning into the absurdity of summing up his characters lives as a kind of afterthought, maybe he could have enjoyed seeing other people interpret his worlds, after all?

Chapple and Godwin have forged a creative partnership that has rightly garnered acclaim in Sydney. A Room with a View is a smart, funny adaptation and with the shining central character of Lucy rightly bucking against the patriarchy, I think Forster might have loved it.

- Keith Gow, Theatre First

A Room with a View is running at Melbourne Theatre Company’s Southbank Theatre until December 19

Photos: Brett Boardman

Comments